One of the most frustrating things about being the mom of a preschooler is when you make them a healthy, nutritious lunch…and they won’t eat it. So, my goal is to make lunch fun too. These mini fun shapes sandwiches are perfect for preschool lunches and will help your kids want to eat their entire lunch in one sitting.

Mini Fun Shapes Sandwiches - Perfect for preschool lunches, and a great way to get kids interested in eating their lunch.

I made these sandwiches with peanut butter and jelly on white bread, but you could use other peanut butter alternatives if your child or someone in your classroom has a peanut allergy. Our favorite peanut butter alternatives are sunflower butter and soynut butter.

You can serve these fun sandwiches with a frozen berry and spinach smoothie, some microwaved potato chips and teddy bear s’mores for dessert.

Ingredients and Supplies

Mini Cookie Cutters

White bread

Peanut Butter



Lay out your slices of bread and make a few peanut butter and jelly sandwiches as usual.

You will need to make a few sandwiches since you will only be able to make about 4 mini fun shapes sandwiches per regular sandwich. Mom, you will probably be eating the crusts and leftover parts of the sandwich.

Once the sandwiches are made, choose a cookie cutter and press down to cut through the sandwich. These cookie cutters are small so they are about as tall as the sandwich is. You will need to press hard and then twist a little to be sure the bottom cuts all the way through.

Then just pop out your mini sandwich from the cookie cutter. Repeat the process until you have enough mini sandwiches as you think you will need. I was truly surprised at how many mini sandwiches my daughter ate – overall, much more than if she was given a sandwich cut in half.

I love using white bread and peanut butter and jelly because the sandwich gets “sealed” on the edges when you cut through with the cookie cutter. They end up just like the Uncrustables we buy at the store.

Mini Fun Shapes Sandwiches - Perfect for preschool lunches, and a great way to get kids interested in eating their lunch.

My daughter is going to love opening her lunchbox and seeing these mini fun shapes sandwiches waiting for her in a few weeks when preschool starts.

You can also use the cookie cutters to make other things in fun shapes, which I will be sure to share when I can take some pictures. A few ideas for you – french toast fun shapes, quesadilla fun shapes, sugar cookie fun shapes, pancake fun shapes…I could go on and on.

Preschool Lunch Idea: Mini Fun Shapes Sandwiches

Preschool Lunch Idea: Mini Fun Shapes Sandwiches


  • Mini cookie cutters
  • White bread
  • Peanut Butter
  • Jelly
Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by Yummly Rich Recipes

You might also like:

Preschool Lunch Idea - Ham and cheese roll upPreschool Lunch Idea: Ham and Cheese Roll Up

Back to Preschool - Free Printable Checklist

Back to School Preschool Printable Checklist


If you liked this post and want to see more of Practical Mommy, please sign up for the weekly email below.

Need to get organized? Join the Club!


Download your FREE goal planning sheets inside the Practical Printables Club!

Unsubscribe anytime - no hard feelings. Powered by ConvertKit

1 Comment on Preschool Lunch Idea: Mini Fun Shapes Sandwiches

  1. Melinda
    August 24, 2015 at 4:56 pm (2 years ago)

    So cute! I’m here from Inspire Me Monday. I clicked on your pic, and it said oops something went wrong. But I love these shape sandwiches!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comment *